Drugstore biggie, Neutrogena also began as a skincare brand and took its philosophy along when they expanded to makeup. Their makeup products are targeted to conceal and care for your skin imperfections. Their products are formulated with naturally derived ingredients and devoid of talc, fragrance or dyes. With ophthalmologist -tested eye makeup, you can trust this brand blindly!

Driven by natural ingredients, Burt's Bees makes more than their iconic lip balm: The brand also has a whole range of makeup, from foundation to lipstick and beyond. The collection includes this lengthening mascara, which is gentle enough for sensitive eyes.